The Dobbs Wire: Another section of Pennsylvania’s registration law ruled UNconstitutional

Pennsylvania:  Aftershocks from a recent groundbreaking Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruling continue.  Now a mid-level appeals court, the Pennsylvania Superior Court, has ruled another part of the state’s sex offense registration law violates both the state and federal constitution.  The case involved a man who had consensual sex with a minor dozens of times and was designated a ‘sexually violent predator’ (SVP), a label that carries extra stigma and penalties.  The court overturned his designation, ruled the current SVP designation process unconstitutional, and laid out constitutional standards for the future, calling for the legislature to take action.   Congratulations to Joseph Butler…

Continue reading

The Dobbs Wire: NO ability to resist stupid ideas

Sat, Nov 4, 2017 at 12:01 PM Residency restrictions is the polite term for banishment laws that are on the books in many states and cities around the country.  The laws target people on the sex offense registry and are usually wreathed in child protection rhetoric.  Are they effective?   Investigative reporter Eric Dexheimer did some serious digging and has a story about Meadows Place, a Texas town that’s fixing to rip a resident right out of her own house.  His article has plenty more about how residency restrictions are used to run people out of town and keep them out…

Continue reading

The Dobbs Wire: as SOON as the scarlet letter list is ready – IML

Thu, Nov 2, 2017 at 10:38 AM An awful new federal law is one step closer:   As soon as Homeland Security prepares a list of people subject to International Megan’s Law (IML), the US State Department will begin putting permanent scarlet letters on their passports.  Such treatment of US citizens is likely unprecedented – searches have not turned up anything similar in this country’s history.  Current passports of those on the list are going to be revoked.  The State Department has just revealed the message to be emblazoned inside new passports:  “The bearer was convicted of a sex offense against…

Continue reading

The Dobbs Wire: Scarlet letter for PASSPORTS revealed by Trump Administration

Mon, Oct 30, 2017 at 3:44 PM Ugh!  The Trump Administration reveals how it will implement International Megan’s Law (IML).  An awful bill signed into law by Obama in 2016, IML requires anyone previously convicted of a sex offense involving a minor to have a “unique identifier” – a “visual designation affixed to a conspicuous location” on their passport!  Nothing like this has turned up in US history, the IML scarlet letter is likely the first time US citizens are to be treated in such a fashion by their government.  This scheme, however, does have historical precedent in other countries…

Continue reading

The Dobbs Wire: A Modest Proposal – REBOOT!!

Thu, Oct 26, 2017 at 1:36 AM A modest proposal:   Miriam Aukerman has a modest proposal for changing Michigan’s sex offense registry law, the registry laws in other states and a federal statute (SORNA), too!  In a commentary published by The Hill she makes a strong plea for public safety while urging bold changes in how lawmakers – and the public – ought to reckon with sexual wrongdoing.  Her perspective is all the more valuable for having convinced a federal appeals court to issue a ground-breaking 2016 decision that did serious damage to Michigan’s scarlet letter machinery.  The aftershocks from…

Continue reading

The Dobbs Wire: Mothers fighting for reason and justice for their sons

Mon, Oct 23, 2017 at 1:14 PM College campuses:  For years a battle has raged on many college campuses–how to reckon with and even define sexual wrongdoing.  It’s a high tension controversy with high stakes, spurring mothers to organize and stand together, fighting for reason and justice for their sons.  The New York Times has a report on this important facet of the battle, have a look.  –Bill Dobbs, The Dobbs Wire       New York Times | Oct. 22, 2017 ‘Willing to Do Everything,’ Mothers Defend Sons Accused of Sexual Assault     By Anemona Hartocollis and Christina Capecchi…

Continue reading

The Dobbs Wire: First Amendment WIN, court overturns REGISTRY law restrictions

Kentucky win:   A federal court judge in Kentucky just struck down two parts of Kentucky’s sex offense registration law!  Individuals on the registry were banned from using social media, and required to divulge so-called internet identifiers–email addresses and such.  Today’s ruling overturns both restrictions and strengthens the First Amendment rights of everyone to use the Internet. The Kentucky decision builds on a major US Supreme Court victory (Packingham v. North Carolina) that came in June when the court unanimously ruled unconstitutional a North Carolina law banning registrants from social media.  Congratulations and kudos to “John Doe”— a subscriber to The…

Continue reading

The Dobbs Wire: Suzi is found, decades later

57 years ago a campus sex scandal made the news.  Mark Oppenheimer takes a long look back at what happened, tracking down those who were involved, and raising important questions about how sexual wrongdoing is handled in the internet age, with sex offense registries and far higher stakes.  Have a look!  -Bill Dobbs, The Dobbs Wire      The Tablet | Aug. 21, 2017   image001.png@01D337E9.FAD7CA30″ style=”width: 525px; height: 215px;”>   SUZI AT YALE A look back at the original American campus sex scandal, and whose lives it actually changed   By Mark Oppenheimer   Excerpts:  The girl was named Suzi….

Continue reading

The Dobbs Wire: Major changes to California registry – governor signs reform bill

 Fri, Oct 6, 2017 at 8:54 PM California:  Major changes are coming to the country’s largest (over 105,000 individuals) and oldest (1947) sex offense registry.  Anyone registered in California is listed for life; the state had become an outlier, one of just four states with such a harsh lifetime-registration law.  Soon California will have a so-called tiered sex offense registry, the same type of scarlet letter machinery used by nearly every other state.  Just signed by the governor, the new law comes after two reform efforts failed in recent years.  The 2017 bill had law enforcement backing and got much…

Continue reading

The Dobbs Wire: Bittersweet!

Bittersweet news from the US Supreme Court:  The court was asked to review two sex offense-related rulings;  yesterday the court said no to both requests.     Here’s the bitter part:  the court refused to review a federal appeals court decision (8th Circuit) concerning Minnesota’s sex offense civil commitment program.  More than 700 individuals are held in locked facilities for ‘treatment’ – not for anything they did in the past but on a hunch about what they might do in the future.  While the program is wreathed with promises of hearings, due process, and treatment regimes, virtually no one has…

Continue reading